Film Title	Critics	Readers	We	LAT	Ebert	Roeper	The Gist
A Year Without Love				yes
After Innocence				yes
Cowboy del Amor				yes
CSA: Confederate States Of America				yes
Darwins Nightmare				yes
Erosion				yes
Fateless				yes
Gille's Wife				yes
Go For Zucker				yes
Iron Island				yes
L'Enfant				yes	up	down
Music From The Inside Out				yes
Our Brand Is Crisis				yes
Street Fight				yes
The Boys of Baraka				yes
The Promise				yes
The Syrian Bride				yes
Unkown White Male				yes	up	up
William Eggleston in the Real World				yes
Abominable				no
Art School Confidential				no	up	up
Blackmail Boy				no
FAQs				no
Iowa				no
Mrs. Palfrey at the Claremont				no
Revolution				no
Surge Of Power				no
The Almost Guys				no
The Drawstring Restraint				no
The Zodiac				no
When a Stranger Calls				no
The Memory Of A Killer					up
The Intruder	A	D+	A	yes			baffling and beautiful
Down to the Bone	A	C+	A-				quietly devastating
Slither	A	B-	B+	yes	down	down	gleefully nasty
Mountain Patrol: Kekexili	A	B+	N/A	so-so			stimulating
King Kong	A	B-	A-	yes	up	up	What a movie!
Dave Chappelle's Block Party	A	B+	A	yes	up	up	richly amusing and highly contagious.
The Devil's Miner	A	D	A	yes			a sobering day trip
United 93	A	B+	A-	so-so	up	up	stunning
Be Here to Love Me: A Film About Townes Van Zandt	A	C+	A				A heartfelt and impressionistic portrait
The Lady in Question Is Charles Busch	A	F	N/A				affectionate, energetic
Metal: A Headbanger's Journey	A	B-	B+	yes			Superbly crafted
Brick	A	B+	A	yes			endlessly clever
On the Outs	A	C+	B+	yes			a gritty, well-acted, documentary-style drama
Lady Vengeance	A	A-	N/A				intense emotional wallop.
Caché	A	B-	A	yes			penetrating and absorbing
Friends With Money	A	C+	A-				funny, angry, lyrical
Awesome: I F**kin' Shot That	A	C	B+	yes			hypnotic
Good Night, and Good Luck	A	B	N/A		up	up	elegant and stirring
Kiss Kiss, Bang Bang	A	B+	A-				deliriously enjoyable
Little Fish	A	C+	N/A				supple, accomplished, and utterly absorbing
Paradise Now	A	B+	A				puts a human face on the headlines.
Inside Man	A	B+	A	yes	down	up	brilliant
Neil Young: Heart of Gold	A	B	A	yes			superbly crafted
The Passenger	A	B-	N/A				looks better now than it did then, in part because it's so clearly dated.
Wallace & Gromit: Curse of the Were-Rabbit	A	B+	N/A		up	down	a whimsical success of a very high order
Sir! No Sir!	A	C-	A				an exultant, even elated tone.
The Constant Gardener	A	B	N/A		up	up	This is one of the year's best films.
Water	A	B-	N/A	yes	up	up	deeply satisfying
I Am a Sex Addict	A	C	D	no			one-of-a-kind
Capote	A	C	N/A				Viciously good.
New York Doll	A	B+	B				a tender take on life after stardom.
Akeelah and the Bee	A	B+	B+	so-so	up	up	Splendiferous.
Joyeux Noël	A	B	B+	yes	up	up	proudly old-fashioned
Brokeback Mountain	A	C-	A	yes	up	up	a landmark film and a triumph
Thank You for Smoking	A-	B+	B-	yes	up	up	sleek, clever and cocky
Pride and Prejudice	A-	A-	A	yes			A movie for the age, and a keeper for the ages
Sophie Scholl: The Last Days	A-	B+	A	yes			gripping, moving
Separate Lies	A-	C+	N/A				As the couple in distress, Wilkinson and Watson are pitch perfect.
Evil	A-	B	C+	no			not a conventional [horror film].
Ballets Russes	A-	C+	A	yes			enormously absorbing
Walk the Line	A-	B	B+	yes			a strongly acted, musically vibrant, conventionally satisfying biopic
Somersault	A-	C	B+	yes			dreamy, sexy, rather chilly
Syriana	A-	B-	C+	yes	up	up	this fighting-mad film isn't just hot, it's incendiary.
The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada	A-	B	B	yes	up	up	blistering modern Western from first-time director Tommy Lee Jones.
Clean	A-	B-	B+				scrupulous straight-forwardness
Through the Fire	A-	B	C				Call it the anti-Hoop Dreams.
The Ice Harvest	A-	C+	B+				Funny, tense, and exceedingly well made
Nine Lives	A-	C+	N/A		up	up	A beautifully realized experimentation
Eight Below	A-	B+	B	no	up	down	clean, classical, hooray-for-the-pooches
Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire	A-	A-	A-	yes			The best one yet.
Munich	A-	C	B-	so-so	up	up	spectacularly gripping and unsettling
Find Me Guilty	A-	B	B	yes	up	up	[Diesel's] insouciance charms
Everything Is Illuminated	A-	B+	N/A				Schreiber's heartfelt project earns points for disciplined ambition.
Deep Sea 3D	A-	B-	N/A	yes			a great companion piece to Finding Nemo
Pulse	A-	B	B-				Pulse sometimes plods.
Tristram Shandy: A Cock and Bull Story	A-	D+	A	yes	up	up	the first great, mind-tickling treat of the new movie year.
The Child	A-	C+	A				demands patience.
Ushpizin	A-	B	C-				pic's genial warmth never feels overtly preachy
16 Blocks	A-	B	C+	yes	up	down	promising but wasted
Transamerica	A-	B-	B	so-so			Impressively realized on all levels
Three of Hearts	A-	C-	C				above-average for fly-on-the-wall documentary.
The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe	A-	B	B	yes	up	up	Lavish and detailed
A History of Violence	A-	C+	N/A	yes	up	up	Tense and atmospheric
Corpse Bride	A-	B+	N/A				The Oscar for this year's Best Animated Feature Film belongs right here
The Devil and Daniel Johnston	A-	C+	A	no	up	up	candid, clear-eyed
Adam & Steve	A-	C	B+	so-so			well-timed slapstick
The Matador	B+	B-	C+		up	up	[Brosnan's] meatiest role ever
On a Clear Day	B+	B-	C-				intelligently sentimental
Look Both Ways	B+	B-	N/A	yes			imaginative, humorous and truthful
Hard Candy	B+	B-	D	no	up	up	a superficial wallow
Serenity	B+	A-	N/A				never takes itself too seriously.
Sarah Silverman: Jesus Is Magic	B+	D	A	yes			Sarah Silverman is the most outrageously funny woman alive.
The Beauty Academy of Kabul	B+	C	B+	yes			feminist optimism
The Notorious Bettie Page	B+	B-	A-	no	up	up	frisky and fascinating
Ice Age: The Meltdown	B+	B+	C-				perky
Herbie Hancock: Possibilities	B+	C+	N/A	no			buoyant and fluid.
ATL	B+	B+	B-		up	down	lively
Duck Season	B+	C+	A	yes	up	up	tender and droll
Why We Fight	B+	B-	B-	yes			passionate and sobering documentary
Unknown White Male	B+	C+	B+				In theory, [it] ought to be a fascinating movie.
The Squid and the Whale	B+	D+	N/A		up	up	Tender, cruel, and very funny
Red Eye	B+	B	N/A				white-knuckle fun
Game 6	B	B	N/A	no	up	up	dense and mundane.
The New World	B	B-	A-	yes			evocative yet slow-moving
In Her Shoes	B	B	N/A				while it's well-acted on most counts, it's also as plodding as it is obvious.
Winter Passing	B	B	C	no	up	up	so grindingly predictable
Hostel	B	B-	B+	no			both cathartic and unnerving
The White Countess	B	C+	B+	so-so			a typically classy period piece
Match Point	B	C-	B	so-so	up	up	Well-observed and superbly cast
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory	B	B	N/A				Entertaining and fabulously imaginative
Christmas in the Clouds	B	B	N/A				warm and fuzzy exercise in escapism
Trudell	B	C	B-	no			More hagiography than history
Something New	B	C	B+	so-so	up		the rare movie that delivers on its title's promise.
Mrs. Henderson Presents	B	B-	B-	yes	up	down	A thoroughly entertaining crowd-pleaser.
Protocols of Zion	B	C+	B+				Disturbing and surprisingly funny
The Hills Have Eyes	B	B	B-		down	down	particularly gory
The World's Fastest Indian	B	B+	B				a pleasingly whimsical and slyly mischievous road movie
Curious George	B	B	B	yes	up		an endearing little trifle
Tsotsi	B	B+	B	yes	up	up	has vital, urban energy
Bubble	B	C	B-	so-so	up	up	interesting, almost in spite of itself.
Guys and Balls	B	D+	D	yes			crowd-pleasing
The Big Question	B	D	N/A				surprisingly witty
Shopgirl	B	B-	D+		up	up	all too wistfully satisfied with not giving enough.
The Prize Winner of Defiance, Ohio	B	B-	N/A				shameless Eisenhower-era corn.
The Weather Man	B	B-	C+				overbearingly glum
Roving Mars	B	B-	N/A				scarcely affecting
Don't Trip … He Ain't Through With Me Yet!	B	B+	N/A				a revival meeting
March of the Penguins	B	B	N/A				sometimes harrowing, sometimes hokey, sometimes heartwarming
Glory Road	B	B-	B+	yes	up	up	inspirational and thrilling.
Aquamarine	B	B	B	no	down	down	floppy production
North Country	B-	B-	C-		up		respectable though predictable
Jarhead	B-	B	B-		up	up	tough yet tentative
The Shaggy Dog	B-	B-	C-	no	down	down	Do not underestimate
Don't Tell	B-	B-	N/A	yes			Dr. Phil-inspired
MirrorMask	B-	B	N/A				endlessly inventive with creativity to burn.
Take the Lead	B-	B+	B+				doesn't suck.
La Mujer de Mi Hermano	B-	B+	C	yes			Soapy melodrama
Lucky Number Slevin	B-	B+	C-				convoluted
The Pink Panther	B-	B	C-	yes			a passable slapstick comedy
Nanny McPhee	B-	B-	A-	yes			charming and painless.
Looking for Comedy in the Muslim World	B-	C-	D	so-so			The laughs are decidedly hit-and-miss.
Where the Truth Lies	B-	C	B-				terrific and gorgeous looking mystery movie.
Ellie Parker	B-	C+	C-		up	up	scattershot Hollywood spoof
Free Zone	B-	B-	N/A				thrives on its performances
Kinky Boots	B-	C+	D	yes	up	down	sluggishly paced
The Work and the Glory: American Zion	B-	B	N/A				To call this drama heavy-handed would be stating the obvious.
Lonesome Jim	B-	C	B		up	up	a toast-dry farce
Battle in Heaven	B-	D	B	yes			a disappointing turn-off.
The Dying Gaul	B-	C	B+				Fascinating though flawed
The 40-Year-Old Virgin	B-	B+	N/A				unconscionably funny sex farce
Three … Extremes	B-	B	A				too stylized and preassembled to be truly unnerving
Stick It	B-	B+	B	no	down	down	fake
The Wedding Crashers	B-	B+	N/A				Amiable and hollow
Summer Storm	B-	C+	C-	yes			grows exasperating
Dreamer	B-	B+	A-				Modestly engaging but mostly unexceptional
Sky High	B-	B	N/A				Smartly written and sprightly played
Don't Come Knocking	B-	B	D+	no	down	up	a problematic picture
Prime	B-	B-	B		up	up	just more conventional schmaltz
Oliver Twist	B-	C+	N/A				Accomplished if lacking in urgency
Casanova	B-	B-	C	yes	down	up	a stylish and sexy comedy for grownups.
Lord of War	B-	B	N/A				Cage is brilliant.
Breakfast on Pluto	B-	C+	A-	no	up	down	lyrical but shallow
The Producers	B-	B	D+	no			undeniably stagy, even clunky
Memoirs of a Geisha	C+	C	C+	no	down	up	It's not a great movie  but it's spectacular.
The Greatest Game Ever Played	C+	B+	N/A		up	down	mostly sits there limply
Last Holiday	C+	B	B-	yes	up	up	a breezy escapist romp
The Ringer	C+	B	F	yes			close to being a promotional film for the Special Olympics
Hoodwinked	C+	B-	D	yes			fast-paced, fitfully clever
The Libertine	C+	B-	C-	no			ending up tiresome
Just Like Heaven	C+	B+	N/A		up	up	more mushy than madcap
Proof	C+	B-	N/A		up	up	elegant, intelligent drama
The Transporter 2	C+	B	N/A				ridiculously entertaining
Failure to Launch	C+	B-	D+	no	down	down	fails
The Sentinel	C+	B	C-	yes	up	up	very humdrum
The Sisters	C	B-	C-	no	down	up	overcooked
Madea's Family Reunion	C	A-	C-				confused storytelling
Moonlight	C	D	B-				creepily compelling
Dirty	C	B-	C-	no	up	down	Collins is capable of better (see Capote).
The Lost City	C	B+	C+	no	up	up	Compelling in fits and starts
Rent	C	B+	C-	no		up	not an update so much as a throwback.
A Good Woman	C	C	C	no			Pleasant and undemanding
Preaching to the Choir	C	C+	N/A				awkward
Killer Diller	C	B	N/A				lively
She's the Man	C	B+	D+	yes	up	down	spunky if often erratic
One Bright Shining Moment: The Forgotten Summer of George McGovern	C	D+	C+				instructive but aggressively biased
Marebito	C	C+	N/A				a misfired doodle
Dear Wendy	C	B-	N/A				well made but unlikable and dramatically absurd
Just Friends	C	B	C	no	down	down	Just lousy.
The Second Chance	C	A-	N/A	no			Startlingly direct if unavoidably preachy
Phat Girlz	C	B-	D				has moments of charm
Sorry, Haters	C	D	N/A				sorry indeed.
When Do We Eat?	C	B-	B+	no	down	down	more well-intentioned than funny
Ask the Dust	C	B-	C-	so-so	up	up	It's lifeless kitsch.
Freedomland	C	C	D	no	down	up	disjointed and ultimately unsatisfying
American Gun	C	C-	D	no	up	up	Skittishly paced
Flightplan	C	B-	N/A				See Jodie worry! See Jodie run!
American Dreamz	C	C+	C-	yes	up	down	disappointingly soft
The Tenants	C	C+	N/A				bleakly funny
Saw II	C	B+	C-				lags behind in Saw's novelty
Illusion	C	B-	N/A				wins points for originality.
Scary Movie 4	C	B	C-				hit-or-miss
Tristan & Isolde	C	B+	D		up	down	gloomy, awkwardly clipped drama
Roll Bounce	C	B	N/A				buoyant without being brainless
Rumor Has It …	C-	C+	F	no	up		a bland romance spiced with too little comedy.
Madagascar	C-	B-	N/A				Great visuals, lousy plot.
Marilyn Hotchkiss' Ballroom Dancing and Charm School	C-	C-	D-		down	down	a disaster.
RV	C-	B	B-	no	down	down	laughless gags
First Descent	C-	B+	B+				It's dull enough to make a Mormon fidget
Firewall	C-	B-	D	no	up	down	flabby and familiar.
Wolf Creek	C-	C	C+	no			There's no substitute for bad taste.
Stoned	C-	C-	N/A	no			dead on arrival.
Elizabethtown	C-	C+	C-		up	up	a sprawling mess
Get Rich or Die Tryin'	C-	B-	C-		up	up	ambitious, accomplished, but often frustrating
G	C-	B-	N/A				sleek if dramatically flimsy
Underworld: Evolution	C-	C+	D	yes			silly but undeniably entertaining
I Love Your Work	C-	B-	C-				wallow in Hollywood hipster self-absorption.
What the Bleep!? — Down the Rabbit Hole	C-	C+	N/A				won't make you feel stupid.
Domino	C-	C+	C-				fatally hip and lethally numb.
Fun With Dick and Jane	C-	B	D	no	down	down	a flaccid, humorless update
Four Brothers	C-	B+	N/A				It's a head-on collision.
Night Watch	C-	B+	B-	yes	down	down	top-flight and effectively gruesome
Standing Still	C-	B	N/A	no	down	up	shallow
The Wild	C-	C+	D		up	down	been-there-seen-that.
Imagine Me & You	C-	B	C				blithely synthetic
Running Scared	C-	B+	D	no	up	down	giddily awful, awfully giddy action noir
Chicken Little	C-	D+	C				a clunky, arbitrarily plotted, over-caffeinated spritz
The Gospel	C-	B	N/A				banal, artless, cliché-ridden fiction
39 Pounds of Love	C-	D	C-				the feature feels padded even at 70 minutes.
The Family Stone	C-	B-	D	yes			These people are awful, and it's hard not to want bad things to happen to them.
Two for the Money	D+	C+	N/A				turns from ludicrous to incoherent
Derailed	D+	B-	D				a junky thriller
Manderlay	D+	C	C+	no			disappointing
Cheaper by the Dozen 2	D+	B	D				Formulaic and forced
Date Movie	D+	C+	F	no			a lame pastiche of Hollywood romances.
Basic Instinct 2	D+	C-	D	no	down	down	deliciously awful
Doogal	D+	C-	C-				slapdash dialogue and smug vocal talent
The Legend of Zorro	D+	B	C-				considerably less charming than its predecessor
Silent Hill	D	B	C	no			does not disappoint.
Tamara	D	C+	N/A				a familiar B-grade mix of excessive gore and insufficient imaginativeness.
Big Momma's House 2	D	B-	D	no			unnecessary but genial
In Her Line of Fire	D	D+	N/A				passable action trash
End of the Spear	D	B+	C-	no			dogmatically histrionic tribute to missionary work
Stay Alive	D	B-	D+				so idiotically directed
Grandma's Boy	D	B	B	no			The acting is more wooden than Pinocchio's Christmas pageant
BloodRayne	D	C-	F	no			Half woman, half vampire, total baloney
Larry the Cable Guy: Health Inspector	D	B-	B				on a level for six-year-olds
The Exorcism of Emily Rose	D	B-	N/A				a retread of a retread
Final Destination 3	D	B+	B+	no			a desultorily plotted affair
Bee Season	D	C	B+				the film is ice cold
Kids in America	D-	C+	C+				a trite teen comedy burdened with lofty aspirations
Doom	D-	B-	B-		down	down	a formulaic shoot'em-up
Duane Hopwood	D-	C	N/A				the definition of bland.
In the Mix	D-	C	D-				A badly stuffed turkey.
Annapolis	D-	B-	D	no	down	down	conspicuously myopic and reactionary
Yours, Mine and Ours	D-	B-	C+	no			a blandly wishy-washy proposition.
The Benchwarmers	D-	B+	D				cinema's new Terrible Three
April's Shower	D-	D+	D+	no			arch and undernourished comedy
Ultraviolet	D-	C+	B-				soulless sentimentality
Neal 'n' Nikki	F	C	N/A				dialogue and plotting are weak
Into the Blue	F	C+	N/A				A dive into the most unconvincing of melodrama.
The Fog	F	C-	D-				a countdown to boredom.
An Unfinished Life	F	B-	N/A		up	up	never realizes its dramatic potential
Waiting	F	B+	N/A		down	down	practically screams rental.
The Cave	F	C	N/A				solid if unspectacular