| Film Title | Critics | Readers | We | LAT | Ebert | Roeper | The Gist |
| Eastern Promises | yes | up | . | ||||
| 4 Months | yes | . | |||||
| Blame It on Fidel | yes | . | |||||
| Colma: The Musical | yes | . | |||||
| Crossing the Line | yes | . | |||||
| Czech Dream | yes | . | |||||
| Flying: Confessions of a Free Woman, | yes | . | |||||
| Live-in Maid | yes | . | |||||
| Milarepa: Magician, Murderer, Saint | yes | . | |||||
| Park | yes | . | |||||
| Primo Levi's Journey | yes | . | |||||
| Sharkwater | yes | . | |||||
| Strange Culture | yes | . | |||||
| Summer '04 | yes | . | |||||
| Them | yes | . | |||||
| Total Denial | yes | . | |||||
| Choking Man | so-so | . | |||||
| Marigold | so-so | . | |||||
| Resident Evil: Extinction | N/A | A- | N/A | so-so | the first one is still the best | ||
| Summercamp! | so-so | . | |||||
| The Last Legion | so-so | . | |||||
| 56 Drops of Blood | no | . | |||||
| 7 Dias | no | . | |||||
| Blood and Tears | no | . | |||||
| Broken | no | . | |||||
| Eye of the Dolphin | no | . | |||||
| If I Didn't Care | no | . | |||||
| In a Day | no | . | |||||
| Sea of Dreams | N/A | D | N/A | no | all life has been squeezed out | ||
| Shadow Company | no | . | |||||
| Splinter | no | . | |||||
| The Civilization of Maxwell Bright | no | . | |||||
| The Genius Club | no | . | |||||
| The Shooting Party | no | . | |||||
| Trigger Man | no | . | |||||
| Good Luck Chuck | N/A | B- | N/A | down | some sort of humor-deprivation experiment. | ||
| Beauty Remains | N/A | N/A | N/A | all soft focuses, sax flourishes, and silky slo-mos. | |||
| Klimt | . | ||||||
| Terror's Advocate | A | N/A | A | yes | dense and unsettling | ||
| Fat Girls | A | C- | N/A | no | wins no points for delicacy. | ||
| The King of Kong | A | N/A | N/A | yes | roaringly funny | ||
| Joe Strummer: The Future Is Unwritten | A | N/A | A | yes | has an intimacy that's rare to encounter in rock docs. | ||
| The Unknown Soldier | A | B- | A | no | a telling exploration of Germany's present-day psyche | ||
| Private Property | A | B | A | yes | a script so clear and airtight that shrinks could use it for family therapy courses | ||
| Deep Water | A | C+ | A | a whirlpool of gripping adventure, overblown ambitions and sheer human folly | |||
| Great World of Sound | A | B | N/A | yes | a terrific, small, funny, sad movie | ||
| 3:10 to Yuma | A | B+ | B+ | yes | up | a sturdy and enjoyable remake of the 1957 minor classic | |
| Before the Devil Knows You're Dead | A | B+ | N/A | yes | up | grabs hold and runs you through the wringer. | |
| Outsourced | A | B+ | N/A | has a gentle touch with the obvious fish-out-of-water touchstones. | |||
| Lake of Fire | A | A- | N/A | yes | Smart, visually appealing, and consistently engaging | ||
| No Country for Old Men | A | A- | A | yes | up | a viciously effective exercise in suspense | |
| King Corn | A | A | B+ | yes | a thoughtful meditation on the plight of the American farmer | ||
| Michael Clayton | A | B+ | B | yes | up | Deliberate, demanding and character-driven | |
| Steal a Pencil for Me | A | A- | A | yes | Not your mother's Holocaust movie | ||
| Gone Baby Gone | A | B+ | B+ | so-so | up | a thinking man's crime film | |
| Dan in Real Life | A | B+ | D- | yes | up | deftly interlaces heart and humor | |
| Antonia | A | D+ | B+ | yes | less a candy-coated inspirational pill | ||
| In the Shadow of the Moon | A | B | A | yes | up | A stirring account of the Apollo program's mission to the moon | |
| Desert Bayou | A | B | N/A | yes | a poignant indictment of a social disaster | ||
| The Life of Reilly | A | C- | B+ | prickly wit, gleeful pride and bemused gratitude | |||
| Manda Bala | A | N/A | N/A | yes | loads of dark humor and cinematic flair | ||
| Pete Seeger: The Power of Song | A | A- | N/A | a terrific, multilayered portrait of a singer | |||
| Angels in the Dust | A | B+ | N/A | yes | deftly weaves in the big picture through Cloete's bursts of anger at government ministers and traditional healers | ||
| My Kid Could Paint That | A | C+ | N/A | no | up | an engrossing meditation on truth, media exploitation and the value of art | |
| American Gangster | A | A | N/A | yes | up | one hell of an exciting movie | |
| Darkon | A | C | N/A | yes | clever, lo-fi dorkumentary about fantasy role-players in Baltimore | ||
| Dans Paris | A- | B | N/A | no | a genuinely honest, unpretentious and delightful small film | ||
| Superbad | A- | A- | A | yes | up | packs more gut-busting laughs than you can count. | |
| Into the Wild | A- | A- | B | yes | up | magnificent precision and imaginative grace | |
| For the Bible Tells Me So | A- | C+ | B+ | yes | a shrewd, detailed, eye-opening look | ||
| Delirious | A- | A | N/A | yes | up | speaks with style, verve and genuine wit. | |
| The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford | A- | A- | A | so-so | up | ravishing, magisterial, poetic | |
| In Between Days | A- | N/A | A | plays like a teen movie with all the narration removed | |||
| The Darjeeling Limited | A- | B | A | yes | up | colorful and kinetic | |
| Ladron Que Roba a Ladron | A- | B+ | N/A | an obvious Ocean's Eleven knockoff | |||
| Control | A- | C | A- | up | a riveting, visually arresting portrait of a tormented soul. | ||
| The Bubble | B+ | B | B | so-so | nails the nervous blend of vitality and desperation that is Israel today. | ||
| 2 Days in Paris | B+ | A | B- | up | a steady comedy of embarrassment | ||
| Jimmy Carter Man From Plains | B+ | C | B | no | As complex as its subject | ||
| Exiled | B+ | B | A- | yes | an accomplished suspense-action piece | ||
| The Last Winter | B+ | B+ | C+ | yes | most chilling of global-warming movies. | ||
| The Camden 28 | B+ | C | B | stinging, and finally instructive | |||
| Wristcutters: A Love Story | B+ | B+ | N/A | up | somewhat original and amusing. But only somewhat. | ||
| Rocket Science | B+ | C | B+ | down | ever quite spits out what it has to say. | ||
| I Want Someone to Eat Cheese With | B+ | B | N/A | so-so | up | never completely takes off, yet somewhat overestimates the surrounding zaniness. | |
| In the Valley of Elah | B+ | B- | B- | no | up | a deeply reflective, quietly powerful work that is as timely as it is moving. | |
| The Price of Sugar | B+ | B- | N/A | yes | a solid and affecting piece of work | ||
| Out of the Blue | B+ | B | N/A | Chilling, often moving docudrama | |||
| Skinwalkers | B | B | N/A | sparks an old-fashioned B-movie charge | |||
| Things We Lost in the Fire | B | B+ | B- | yes | up | pretty sharp on the subject of addiction and recovery and relapse. | |
| War/Dance | B | A | B+ | yes | comes across as desperately, even irritatingly contrived | ||
| The Rape of Europa | B | D+ | N/A | yes | Impressive in scope if unremarkable in style | ||
| Hatchet | B | B | B | no | All the key ingredients to make the quintessential gore-fest are there | ||
| Right at Your Door | B | B- | C | no | takes a viewer on a harrowing, distinctly uncomfortable journey. | ||
| Death at a Funeral | B | N/A | C | no | may go a bit over the top | ||
| Shoot 'Em Up | B | B | C- | no | down | a bloody, trashy, volcanically depraved action movie | |
| Sunflower | B | N/A | N/A | serves up solid dramatic values | |||
| The Brave One | B | B+ | C | no | up | keeps things intriguing, with Foster's haunted, fiercely committed performance certain to garner awards attention. | |
| P2 | B | B- | C | a refreshingly old-fashioned thriller | |||
| Stardust | B | B | B+ | up | Everything but the enchanted kitchen sink shows up in the sprawling fairy tale | ||
| The Jane Austen Book Club | B | F | C- | so-so | up | This is a chick flick with a vengeance | |
| Fierce People | B | D | C- | no | down | sometimes bogs down in anthropological metaphor | |
| King of California | B | B- | C+ | yes | down | boasts an eccentric tone, properly whimsical music and problematic father-daughter story | |
| Canvas | B | N/A | N/A | no | a thoughtful, sweet film | ||
| Mr. Untouchable | B | B- | N/A | so-so | a fascinating first-person account | ||
| Kurt Cobain: About a Son | B | B+ | N/A | yes | bold and successful | ||
| Rendition | B- | B | D+ | so-so | down | timely without being gripping. | |
| Lust, Caution | B- | B+ | B+ | yes | up | Too much caution and too little lust | |
| The Nines | B- | B | C+ | so-so | more than enough intelligence, intrigue and performance dazzle | ||
| Illegal Tender | B- | B | D+ | plays like a mash-up of pulp fiction and telenovela | |||
| Closing Escrow | B- | B | N/A | so-so | overall this fixer-upper has very little curb appeal. | ||
| The Hunting Party | B- | B | C | up | Alternately glib, superficial and amusing | ||
| Meeting Resistance | B- | C | N/A | so-so | manages to capture the palpable frustration on the ground | ||
| Self-Medicated | B- | B | N/A | no | has more than its share of teen-angst clichés | ||
| Weirdsville | B- | B+ | N/A | so-so | has some quirky pleasures | ||
| Across the Universe | B- | B+ | D | up | goofy, pompous, annoyingly boomer-myopic Fab Four musical. | ||
| Lions for Lambs | B- | C- | D- | no | Talky, back-bendingly liberal but also deeply patriotic | ||
| Lars and the Real Girl | B- | N/A | A- | yes | down | a deep, sweet-hearted study | |
| DarkBlueAlmostBlack | B- | B | B- | a well-acted soap with one too many plot lines | |||
| Golda's Balcony | B- | B- | N/A | inert yet strangely compelling | |||
| Music Within | B- | B | C- | no | no | collapses under its weighty sense of responsibility. | |
| We Own the Night | B- | A | B- | so-so | down | defiantly, refreshingly unhip. | |
| The 11th Hour | B- | N/A | N/A | yes | yes | has no time for subtlety. | |
| Halloween | B- | B+ | C | this bloodier, higher-body-count version leaves nothing to the imagination | |||
| Dragon Wars | C+ | B | B | no | a feast of A-grade f/x married to a Z-grade, irony-free script. | ||
| The Kingdom | C+ | B+ | C+ | no | up | a realist thriller that mixes crowd-pleasing mayhem with provocative politics. | |
| Finishing the Game | C+ | A- | D | no | a rice-paper-thin spoof | ||
| Resurrecting the Champ | C+ | B- | C- | so-so | the plan of attack is overly sentimentalized and the execution is slack. | ||
| Slipstream | C+ | B+ | N/A | no | bold, experimental | ||
| Fred Claus | C+ | B | C- | so-so | constructed like a rattling Santa sack of stocking stuffers | ||
| The Seeker: The Dark Is Rising | C+ | B- | D+ | no | down | a pretty vivid fantasy book come-to-life | |
| Sleuth | C | N/A | C+ | so-so | down | Visually dull production and uneasy editing | |
| Black Irish | C | A- | B- | so-so | doesn't miss a cliché of hardscrabble adolescence. | ||
| The Game Plan | C | B+ | C- | down | sticks close to the playbook for family-friendly laffers | ||
| 7 Days | C | B+ | N/A | a film that has no sense of its own ridiculousness. | |||
| Cut Sleeve Boys | C | C | N/A | pretty much gay business as usual. | |||
| Martian Child | C | A | B- | no | down | engagingly weird | |
| Saw IV | C | B+ | C- | more than enough here to keep the fans intrigued, entertained, and squirming in their seats. | |||
| Jack Ketchum's The Girl Next Door | C | A- | N/A | makes you wish you could rinse your brain in bleach | |||
| The Invasion | C | B | D | yes | no | a slick but forgettable, characterless thriller. | |
| The Good Night | C | B+ | N/A | As becalmed and refreshing as a good night's sleep | |||
| How to Cook Your Life | C | B | N/A | gentle preaching is still preaching. | |||
| Freshman Orientation | C | C | D | no | a politically incorrect but ultimately exhausted social satire | ||
| Sydney White | C | B+ | D+ | down | It's no Mean Girls or even Clueless | ||
| Death Sentence | C | B+ | C | down | endless amounts of blood spurting, exploding body parts and severed limbs. | ||
| Mr. Bean's Holiday | C | B | D+ | has plenty of chuckles but few outright laughs | |||
| The Final Season | C | A | N/A | no | overscored, underwritten and sometimes awkwardly shot | ||
| Raising Flagg | C | B | N/A | no | slack, homespun synthetic yarn | ||
| Reservation Road | C | B+ | C- | no | down | aims for tragedy but stalls at soap opera. | |
| Trade | C | B+ | N/A | so-so | up | pure exploitation | |
| December Boys | C | B | C- | yes | down | visually well-mounted but narratively muddled | |
| Romance & Cigarettes | C | C+ | B- | alternately shines and sputters. | |||
| Ira & Abby | C | C | N/A | Annie Hall called, and it wants its plot back. | |||
| The Nanny Diaries | C | B- | C | no | rarely rises above standard sitcom fare | ||
| 30 Days of Night | C | B+ | B- | no | down | a catchy premise and quite enough splatter to satisfy gorehounds | |
| Bee Movie | C | B+ | C- | so-so | up | short on surprise and originality. | |
| Darfur Now | C | N/A | N/A | so-so | testimony is only worth so much | ||
| Love for Sale | C | D- | N/A | once you know the title, you pretty much get the gist. | |||
| The Heartbreak Kid | C | B- | B- | no | down | a model of comic timing. | |
| Berkeley | C | N/A | N/A | no | an overambitious period agenda betrayed by an obvious low budget. | ||
| Mr. Woodcock | C- | B | C- | no | down | Uninspired, sure, but sporadically, spasmodically funny. | |
| Rush Hour 3 | C- | A- | C+ | down | stays true to the franchise formula of East-West fusion action | ||
| Balls of Fury | C- | B- | D- | no | down | Relentlessly silly | |
| September Dawn | C- | C- | N/A | no | has the ham-fisted lyricism of political ads and pharmaceutical commercials. | ||
| Descent | C- | C- | N/A | A symposium in the men are pigs school of gender relations | |||
| Elizabeth: The Golden Age | C- | N/A | C | no | down | exquisitely complicated wigs and expensively grand wide shots | |
| The Hottest State | C- | F | C- | up | takes a good deal of time to heat up | ||
| Feast of Love | C- | B- | D | no | up | far too cloyingly pleased with its own humanity. | |
| Hannah Takes the Stairs | C- | C- | N/A | no | The characters in Hannah alternate between unconscious and self-conscious, and that's the charm. | ||
| Saawariya | C- | B+ | N/A | basically inert | |||
| The Ten Commandments | C- | B | N/A | The only saving grace is the voice cast | |||
| Dedication | C- | B | C+ | down | Vaguely uninviting, not-funny-enough touches | ||
| Rails & Ties | C- | B | N/A | no | like one bad TV movie that slammed into another. | ||
| O Jerusalem | D+ | B- | D | adorably clumsy melodrama | |||
| The Brothers Solomon | D+ | C- | D | down | a forced split-the-baby comedy that proves unwise from its very conception. | ||
| Bella | D+ | A- | N/A | no | So slight that a gentle breeze might tip it over | ||
| Silk | D | B | N/A | no | Vacuous, arid and terminally dull | ||
| The Inner Life of Martin Frost | D- | B | N/A | What starts out as a clever exploration of consciousness quickly descends into underplotted folly. | |||
| War | F | B+ | C | no | such a generic plot | ||
| Moving McAllister | F | C | N/A | a perfect storm of low-budget indie conventionality | |||
| The Man of My Life | F | F | C+ | drunk on its own sense of contrived poetry | |||
| Daddy Day Camp | F | D | F | no | down | suffers all the near-classic sequel handicaps |